A small team of editors and designers, working separately, would manage all the details of the print edition, from story selection to final proofing, piggybacking as much as possible on the work of the interactive copy desk. They – not the managing editor, metro editor or senior news editor – would effectively “own” the print edition.
It has gone surprisingly well. We succeeded in resetting the rhythm of the whole newsroom.
We’re no longer focused on the paper tomorrow -- the print team worries about that for all of us.
Instead we’re occupying news editors and copy editors with the work of producing the website 18 hours a day every weekday.
We actually made the mistake of continuing to staff the desk lightly on Friday afternoons and not at all on Friday evenings — as we have since the Missourian ended its Saturday print edition — but soon realized that Fridays had become just like any other weekday — busier than most, actually. We had to adjust.
Interactive copy editors are in charge of our social networks. They regularly use Twitter and Facebook. But we can be more creative and proactive in soliciting reader input for potential stories, rather than just the ones we’ve already posted.
Interactive copy editors also monitor the comment boards at the end of every article. They take down comments that violate our policies, and they jump in when the conversation demands a Missourian response. We think copy editors could do more in mediating conflicts among commenters and soliciting comments on stories that ought to be sparking them but aren’t.
We need to be better, too, at figuring out how to create energy and engagement on the website when the news by itself just isn’t doing it. All these are on our list for tackling in earnest in the spring.
The biggest drawback to the experiment has been the print experience of headline writing for our student copy editors. While they still do an evening print shift every three or four weeks, it’s not enough experience, especially when it comes to headline writing. Writing headlines for print — in a space strictly prescribed — is a skill that only comes with intense practice. It makes them better at writing headlines for the website. We’ll retool for spring to rotate more copy editors into print shifts and, on those shifts, to increase their focus on perfecting their headlines.
However, the benefits of our experiment, which we dubbed The Transition, have far outweighed the drawbacks.
Our website has improved tremendously and, with our interactively focused copy desk, we see room for much more. Meanwhile, our designated print team has done a great job maintaining the print edition. Their exclusive focus on print has even improved the product in some ways. (See print editor Jake Sherlock’s separate report on that aspect of The Transition.) We’ll try to perfect the experiment in the spring. Watch our Transition blog (transition.columbiamissourian.com) for regular updates about what we’re doing on the interactive copy desk and in other aspects of the Missourian newsroom.

Comments
Some of you have asked, and
Some of you have asked, and I'll post a reply for all: Jake Sherlock's report on how the print-only team fared will post soon.
This sounds like a great
This sounds like a great transition strategy. As a young online editor who graduated from journalism school in 2009, my education didn't prepare me to work online and I've been making it up as I go along. It's exciting, but it's also tough to know whether I'm doing things "properly" sometimes because those established processes don't exist yet.
Also, the first thing that popped into my mind regarding learning to write headlines for print is that journalism students should also be learning to write headlines, descriptions and keywords for SEO (search engine optimization) and social media purposes. It will not necessarily replace headline writing for print, but it is becoming an increasingly important skill.
Online headlines have to grab the readers' attention, yes, but they should also be "attractive" to search engines like Google and be able fit into character-restricted social media updates along with your Twitter handle and a shortened URL.
"Online headlines have to
"Online headlines have to grab the readers’ attention, yes, but they should also be “attractive” to search engines like Google" Too true!
Congrats on such a through
Congrats on such a through transformation of your newsroom. The next step: radically changing the number of contributors in your newsroom by removing its walls on putting your newsroom online.
I'd be eager to talk about how the right platform can help! :-)
Gerri Berendzen picked up the
Gerri Berendzen picked up the question of segregating print and digital on the American Copy Editors Society blog: http://www.copydesk.org/board/uncategorized/2011/creating-a-new-copy-edi...
As you have discovered, I
As you have discovered, I find that being a copyeditor qualifies me even more to be the social media advocate for a company. Having a copyeditor manage your social media means that you are posting links and news quickly, efficiently and with few to no grammatical errors. (You save time on having a copyeditor overlook all your tweets.) That's the way to go!
I'd feel much better about
I'd feel much better about this if the job known as "copy editor" were not being systematically decimated across the industry.
All, I'll post the link here
All, I'll post the link here to Jake Sherlock's follow-up on how the print-only team works, for those who find this post first or who have subscribed to these comments. Sherlock is here: http://bit.ly/dQDhfo
@Cassandra -- Totally agree about writing headlines for SEO (we teach that, but we think it's actually more complex than most copy editors allow -- a topic for a future Transition blog post). But the discipline of writing a headline to a print spec definitely makes you a better headline writer, for print and for Web.
@Toby -- Thanks. And we are most definitely working on the question of how to better engage the community in creating content. Kapost is really interesting. I'll be studying that; thanks for the heads-up.
@Marisa -- Totally agree. Social media tasks are well-placed with copy editors. We are beginning to see the copy desk as the place where the newsroom interacts with readers.
@Tom M. -- We're hoping that giving copy editors these interactive skills makes them more indispensible and less easily downsized.
Add Your Comment